Skip to main content

Tag: MMA and UFC Accidents

Chris Bonilla’s Lawsuit Against CalTrans: A Legal Perspective

Bonilla Argues Negligence by the State?

It happened in Los Angeles County. Chris Bonilla was one of the best-known MMA fighters before his gruesome accident 2018. Bonilla crashed into an unmarked barrier. Bonilla claims that the California Department of Transportation did not mark the boundary properly. According to Bonilla, he traveled on the 10 Freeway in West Covina around six a.m. and pulled over to the side of the road.

The results were disastrous. According to TMZ, the former Muay Thai champ has a severe case. This caught my radar, so I wanted to expand with some thoughts from the legal profession.

Photos of the accident show the sheer extent of the damage. Doctors barely saved his leg. However, according to the MMA champ, it may eventually need to be amputated. The photos show extreme damage to his body– and from the looks of it, due to an issue that should not have existed in the first place.

From The Law Side?

Legally, it appears that CalTrans was negligent. The barrier most likely required reflective tape or mirrored reflectors, so negligent maintenance and failure to warn are definitely at issue. The state did not install them. Furthermore, the state has a higher level of responsibility than a homeowner or a small municipality.

If CalTrans had known of the defect, it would have been liable. Also, this issue is likely not isolated to this incident. Every case where CalTrans installed such defective barriers is an injury waiting to happen.

I read the publicly available information on Bonilla’s case. I don’t know every last detail. However, this appears to be relatively open and shut from a legal perspective. No one deserves to lose their leg, especially not someone involved in physical activity.

A jury will likely award some compensation for the accident. How much remains to be seen. Bonilla’s original settlement demand amount remains unknown. If you would like more information on these and similar celebrity car accidents, keep reading our series on MMA and sports injuries. We will update our site with more cases later.

UFC Frank Camacho Car Accident Update

A Detour in Frank Camacho’s Fighting Career – Health Update

Frank the “Crank” Camacho was set to return to action for the first time after one year away from the cage. The UFC fighter was set to face Matt Frevola in UFC 263 but got involved in a car accident, forcing the fighter out of Saturday’s fight.

On June 8th, 2021, Frank Camacho suffered injuries from a serious multi-vehicle collision on the 405 Freeway in Los Angeles. Camacho traveled from Redondo Beach to San Diego when the five-vehicle pileup occurred on the 405. As Camacho’s ’96 Tacoma pickup truck was cruising on the San Diego freeway, they heard a loud screech before a car plowed into the side of their vehicle from out of nowhere. The car hit the metal divider before it flew and landed on a nearby Ferrari, resulting in a multiple-vehicle collision.

While at the scene of the accident, Camacho complained of head, neck, and shoulder pain. Camacho was immediately transported to a local hospital, the Los Alamitos Medical Center, where medical professionals conducted a CT scan and a few X-rays.

The medical tests showed inflammation in Camacho’s ligaments in the neck. Cuki Alvarez, with him in the vehicle, reported the car crash on his Instagram, stating that Camacho suffered from a herniated disc. An MRI revealed confirmed herniation with injuries to the C7 and T1 vertebrae and no word as to whether they can be repaired or pushed back into place. Sadly, car accidents can lead to degenerative disc disease, which would kill his career.

Although the injuries were not believed to be life-threatening, Camacho pulled out of the lightweight bout to focus on recovering. He posted a photo of himself in the hospital bed on his social media account with a caption that said he was heartbroken to withdraw from his fight Saturday at UFC 263 and felt a little beat up.

Camacho wrote in the post that he appreciated the help from the medical staff, his family, friends, and his wife, Sarah and that he was grateful to have walked away from the accident in one piece. He also apologized to Matt Frevola and the UFC for any inconvenience.

He said of the accident,

“I’m absolutely heartbroken” to be forced to “withdraw from my fight.” He asserted the accident was just a “detour in my fighting,” even though it left him with a herniated disc and other injuries.

UFC 263 Fight Saturday Continued Without Frank

Frank Camacho has been out of the cage for nearly a year since losing his match to Las Vegas, Nevada native Justin Jaynes, who knocked him out. He has struggled to keep his standing. His first match after being one year away from the cage was against Brock Weaver, just a couple of months before the accident. However, UFC Lightweight Camacho had to withdraw after receiving a positive on his COVID-19 test.

After suffering from multiple herniated discs due to the accident, Camacho had to withdraw from his fight with Matt Frevola. Frank, “The Crank” Camacho, has dropped out for two out of four of his last five contests with an unsure future. Although the withdrawal shook the UFC lineup negotiations, the event continued with a new fight card entry before the contest to replace Frank Camacho.

It so happened that Frevola had to face Terrance Mckinney. Other UFC fights for the event included Nate Diaz vs. Leon Edwards, Eryk Anders vs. Darren Stewart, Alexis Davis vs. Pannie Kianzad, and many more.

Camacho was a fighter in the cage. To heal, Frank the Crank Camacho will need to be patient and resist the urge to re-injure himself by returning to fighting too soon after his multi-vehicle collision. For now, he is in good spirits. We will keep you abreast of any health update information on behalf of Frank Camacho.

Just like how an accident became a hurdle in Frank Camacho’s rise to fame, it can also affect your life more than you think. Did you suffer injuries from a multi-vehicle car accident in California like Franck Camacho? Did another’s negligence cause it?

Citations:

  • Vox Media, Inc.
  • Brok Weaver
  • MMA Junkie

MMA’s Justin Thornton Bare-Knuckle Fight Death – Can Survivors Sue?

The sports community is sending our deepest condolences and our firm to the family and close friends over fighter Justin Thornton’s August 20, 2021, death.

The incident is not the first in professional wrestling sports or MMA.

Fighters can lose their lives from matches and other factors at the hospital after a fight. He died weeks after suffering a one-hit knockout blow at the BKFC 20 (Bare Knuckle Fighting Championship 20.). Since 2019, 7 fighters have died in MMA events, with many more in unsanctioned cage fighting. In this article, our personal injury attorneys delve into how fighter Justin Thornton died and whether survivors can legally sue the deceased’s opponent in the fight game.

We cover how a decedent’s family can sue for wrongful death against fight event managers, etc. Let’s get into the meat of the story.

Combat Sports Community Devastated by Thornton’s Death

The fight between fighter Justin Thornton and Dillon Cleckler was a rematch of the first fight at Square Ring Promotions-Island Fight 20. Dillon Cleckler faced MMA fighter Justin Thornton at the BKFC 20, where the 39-year-old MMA fighter viciously knocked out Justin Thornton, who fell face-first onto the canvas during the first 18 seconds of the fight.

The fighter was immediately taken to the hospital on a stretcher and remained at the medical center for a few weeks. On September 23, 2021, Amber Willard, dating Thornton then, posted on Thornton’s Facebook account stating that he was partially paralyzed. She updated Thornton’s fans on his social media account that Justin could not breathe properly and was on ventilator support. According to her, he had a lung infection and was also on medication for his spinal injuries.

Unfortunately, the BKFC President, Dave Feldman, confirmed to MMA Fighting the passing away of Justin Thornton on October 4, 2021. The causes of the death remain unknown, with some stating that it was pneumonia. Still, on the day the news of his passing broke, BKFC President Dave Feldman and the combat sports community expressed their grief at the untimely passing of the MMA fighter during his last fight in the first round by knockout.

Dillion Cleckler, a heavy-weight MMA fighter with a professional record of 13 wins and one loss, paid his condolences to Thornton’s family after hearing the news of the fighter’s demise.

Cleckler took his grief to his social media accounts, where he posted on Instagram about how he felt after receiving the news. Cleckler was on his way to training when he found out about Thornton’s passing and was utterly devastated. He mentioned how Thornton was a warrior with an ever-ready fighting spirit and that he was always up for a good fight at any time of the day. Cleckler stated his respect for Thornton and wished prayers for his family before signing off the post with “RIP, Warrior.”

Medical Advisory Warns the Athletic Commission to Exercise Caution

Following the death of Justin Thornton, the Association of Boxing Commissions and Combative Sports (ABC) medical advisory committee issued a statement asking athletic commissions to proceed with caution about bare-knuckle fighting. They stated that minimal data highlighted the risks of combat sports, including a neck compression spinal cord injury, a fighter’s death,

Dr. Michael Schwartz of the ABC medical committee mentioned that most of the fighters in bare-knuckle boxing were older athletes. These older athletes were officially released from fighting for consecutive losses and sustaining multiple injuries and were out of practice in their MMA career histories. However, they could compete in such events as a bare-knuckle fighting championship.

Dr. Schwartz expressed concerns that these older athletes competing were at a higher risk of acute and chronic head injuries. He also pointed out that despite minimum medical recommendations, some jurisdictions do not follow the minimum medical guidelines set by the ABC. Many athletic commissions do not require CT scans or MRIs before clearing a fighter to compete, increasing the medical risks for older athletes already at risk of acute and chronic injuries.

ABC president Mike Mazzulli (director of Mohegan Tribe Department of Athletic Regulation, CT) reportedly stated that he was:

“… surprised that a tragic outcome like Thornton’s death “had not happened any sooner.”

The ABC Medical Committee urged enhanced individual fighter safety screening by a board-certified neurologist before their bare-knuckle fights.

What Happens If an MMA Fighter Kills Their Opponent?

Specific violence is generally accepted in sanctioned MMA fights, particularly bare-knuckle boxing matches. Fighters must follow a strict set of rules and regulations for every fight. If they step outside those bounds, they expose themselves to the scrutiny of the law.

Some moves, such as the twelve to six elbow, are illegal to execute in the cage. Bare-knuckle boxing fighters executing such moves on their opponents could be held liable for the death of a bare-knuckle boxing fighter or any injuries sustained due to their illegal actions, depending on the rules. In this case, fighters are deemed to consent to contact within the acceptable course and scope of a bare-knuckle fighting championship, etc.

Exceeding Reasonable Criminal Standards?

Several prosecutions have occurred in combat sports for illegal activities such as tampering with gloves, low blows, and eye gouges. However, even though there have been several deaths in combat sports, no fighters were ever prosecuted for death. This is because there were no illegal actions during the fight, and the fighter who died succumbed to injuries from the sanctioned bout.

If a party believes that rules were not followed during the fight, resulting in the injuries or death of a fighter, they can take the matter to court. If so, charges for murder and criminal battery could be levied.

Civil Wrongful Death Claims

The close family and other approved representatives may have the basis for filing a wrongful death lawsuit or survival action against the event vendors and the fighter who killed the victim. Damages are for lost past, present, and future income like prize money, consortium, and other things depending on the claims brought and by whom. As we learn more, we will immediately update our readers.

Speak With an MMA Fighting Lawsuit Attorney Today

Injuries can occur not only in the UFC ring but also outside. If you suffered injuries from an accident that was not your fault, contact us at +(833) LETS-SUE for a free consultation with our legal experts.

Continue reading

Jessie Henry: MMA Pro and Firefighter Tire Explosion Case

The injuries were sustained in a Louisiana truck explosion, an on-duty accident, around 9 a.m on a Saturday in December.

What Happened?

Henry served as a firefighter at South Bossier Fire District 2 Station No. 4. He maintained a truck tire at one of the district’s stations over the weekend when the tire on the fire truck exploded without warning. Jessie didn’t manage to escape and was declared dead that night.

Witness Testimony

Gray Young, the chief of training for South Bossier Fire District 2, stated, “The inner rim of the tire popped off of the wheel itself and chrome wheel simulator — a chrome hub cap inside of that wheel — struck him, and he was blown approximately 20 feet.” Young also mentioned the mixed martial arts fighter recently started his dream of becoming a paramedic by studying to continue his certification.

The Wrongful Death Accident was Very Serious

He was immediately transported to Ochsner LSU Hospital post-incident; however, this was the hospital where he later died after succumbing to his life-threatening injuries.

A Military History and Community Server

Before becoming a northwest Louisiana firefighter, Jessie served in the U.S. Army for four years and was an active part of the Army Reserves. Furthermore, he had a non-profit that gave scholarships to young students.

The MMA World Lost a Legend

Henry had a 2-2 record as an MMA fighter. His last victory came in against Andy Carrington in April – he won by a split decision. Henry’s previous match was against Craig Grove.

His Family was Ripped Apart

He was survived by his 9-year-old daughter at the time, Karmen. His uncle also worked as a firefighter in Texas. We offer our condolences to his family and friends.

Commentary: Firefighter Jessie Henry Dies on Dec. 18

Authorities haven’t said what kind of maintenance he did when working that day. However, Henry’s family members told sources that a tire sensor hit Jessie in the head.

Attorneys Are Looking at This Case

The attorneys at Circle of Trust have been working with wrongful death, personal injury, and product defect law for eight years. Thus, the nature of the incident brings numerous questions to mind.

Many Questions to Ask

Did the South Bossier Parish Fire District 2 in LA have a normal maintenance program in place prior to the accident? Was the maintenance process fully overseen and followed? What was the nature of the maintenance that Henry was doing? Henry worked at the station for four years, according to the report – was adequately qualified to conduct the work he was doing when the tire exploded? What is the tire’s model, make, and identification number?

Government Mandates

The government mandates that all tires have an identification number indicating the manufacture date and location. Every tire in America can be traced back to the specific facility that was created using that ID number.

The Verdict: Jessie Henry MMA Pro and Firefighter Tire Explosion

A Fire Truck Tire Exploded – Someone Has to Pay

Jessie Henry was a brilliant firefighter, killed in an on-duty wrongful death accident on Saturday, Dec. 18. This truck explosion case may appear tragic. Yet, it could be because of a manufacturing flaw. A complete inquiry must be made on the tire and every tread piece. The surviving family members may be entitled to significant compensation as part of a product liability lawsuit.

Citations:

  • Gray Media Group
  • CBA News, Las Vegas

MMA’s Brendan Schaub Wrong Way Car Killing Hero

Since multiple UFC fights are scheduled for June and July 2022, we feel that it is the right time to talk about a story involving a UFC fighter that left the state of California in complete shock. On August 12, 2021, a devastating accident became big news as it involved the former UFC fighter, Brendan Schaub.

Schaub stated:

“There’s two kids, and there’s a bigger kid, and he keeps going, ‘I don’t want to die, I don’t want to die,’ and I go, ‘You’re not going to die, buddy, you’re not going to die.”

Learn About Latest MMA Hero Exploits Here

Receive a Free Consultation Today! At Ehline Law, our injury attorneys like to explore legal issues and create awareness of what is going on in America. This article will go over the incident that led to this horrific accident and the MMA’s Brendan Schaub wrong-way car killing hero story.

Encino’s Hero, Brendan Schaub, Saves Four Children

The accident occurred at 7 PM on August 12, 2021, and four days later, Brendan Schaub got into all the details of the accident on his “The Fighter and The Kid” podcast. The former UFC fighter, Brendan Schaub, said he was heading to a restaurant with his spouse, Joanna Zanella, in Encino, California. On his way, he saw a tractor-trailer blocking the 101 freeway. As he got his car closer to the scene, Schaub noticed a child waving his hand from the top of a mangled vehicle, a distress call for help.

Schaub immediately drew his spouse’s attention to the horrific car wreck. She suggested he keep driving and let law enforcement authorities take care of the situation. However, Brendan Schaub noticed two more kids inside the crumpled vehicle and immediately went to the vehicle without a second thought. Brendan Schaub got out of his car and told his wife to stay in the vehicle for safety.
Schaub approached the mangled car and saw another guy at the accident scene. Presuming that he may be the tractor driver, Schaub diverted his attention to the severely damaged vehicle. He noticed three kids and one older child who was traumatized by the incident as he kept yelling, “I don’t want to die.”

Reassuring the children that they were safe, Schaub tried to hinge the door open but failed as the crash caused the door to intertwine with the vehicle. Brendan Schaub hurriedly broke the partially broken window and started pulling the kids out.

After getting all the kids out, Brendan Schaub saw something grave in the corner of his eye. He glanced into the front seat and saw the children’s mother behind the wheel, who was already dead from her tragic collision. According to Brendan Schaub, the front seat was thoroughly soaked in blood, and brain matter was everywhere.

  • Schaub Takes Action to Shield Kids From the Car Crash Gore

Horrified at what he saw, he quickly turned toward the kids, who wanted to look at their mom to see if she was doing okay. Schaub, acting like their big brother, pulled the kids, who were crying for their mother, towards himself to prevent the children from witnessing the gruesome incident.

He mentioned in the podcast that he saw a Mexican man in his tank top with no shoes on fleeing from the accident scene. The man was hit by a Dodge Durango while crossing the freeway.

Brendan Schaub said he tried to hold back his tears during the podcast as he further explained how scary the situation was for him and the children. He mentioned that the SUV had hit the tractor in the gas tank, causing the gas to flood out. Brendan Schaub had his clothes soaked in gas and was afraid of a fire breaking out from spilling gasoline caused by the car crash.

When Brendan was assured that the two women would stay with the kids until the emergency services arrived, Schaub left. Brendan Schaub explained in his podcast why he didn’t wait until first responders arrived. It was because he was afraid of pulling his wife into the situation and didn’t want to stick around as the place was dangerous and highly volatile, with gasoline odor everywhere.

Witnesses at the Crime Scene

Schaub was not the only one at the crime scene. In the podcast, he mentioned another woman, Rita Campos, at the location of the accident. After saying Campos in his podcast, media outlets started to reach out to Campos to understand the story from her point of view.
Campos recalled that she was on her way home from work and was a bit far from a tractor-trailer in front of her. She saw an SUV coming on the wrong side of the freeway, and, to her shock, she saw the SUV slam into the tractor, causing a wrong-way crash. Campos immediately swerved her vehicle and parked it on the road.

She also reported that she saw another woman and Schaub at the accident scene as she got out of her car. She asked Schaub whether he called 911, and in that instance, she heard a “thud” sound. Campos stated that she was 100% certain that she saw a man get hit by a black SUV as he tried to flee by crossing the 101 freeway. Although she could not guarantee whether the man got hit by a Dodge Durango, she saw him get hit, and her statement matched the one Schaub provided in his podcast.

During this time, Schaub was already near the mangled car, and soon Campos followed as he tried to rescue the children. There was another man too, who tried to pry the doors open but failed. Schaub cleared the broken window of the shards of glass and took the kids out. He had handed one of the babies to Campos and the other to the other woman who was also at the accident scene.

Campos stated that Schaub rescued the children within 5 to 6 minutes before leaving. The first responders arrived 10 minutes after Schaub left. Concerned for the kids, she stayed for as long as the officers required her to care for the children.

Campos Remembers Her Heartbreak Exchange

Campos didn’t shy away from giving all the details possible about the accident to the media. She wanted to help law enforcement as much as possible. Campos recalled a conversation with the oldest child (The “chubby one”) from the accident. She mentioned how the child kept stating, “We don’t have a home anymore,” and that their mother was going to heaven.

The child asked Campos whether they would still go to heaven after the accident. Shaken by the conversation, Campos assured the child that one day he would go to heaven, but today he must remain brave and take care of his family since he was the oldest child.

Skeptics Started to Doubt Schaub’s Traumatic Incident

After the release of his podcast, Schaub faced serious doubts from people on social media about his involvement in the traumatic incident, with some believing that he fabricated the entire story. Most skeptics believe that he left the accident scene without speaking to the authorities; hence there is no proof of him being there.

Some of the skeptics thought that the details provided by Schaub were outrageous. Torres getting hit by a car while crossing the freeway, the gasoline flooding, and how Schaub removed the kids from the mangled car were some of the details that skeptics found hard to believe.

Campos saw many social media posts creating doubts about Schaub’s presence at the accident scene. Feeling bad for Schaub, Campos took her frustrations to social media with a post stating that Schaub was there and his story was accurate. She noted that Schaub was a minute earlier than her at the accident site, and when she arrived, Schaub was already trying to pry open the car door.

Many skeptics also argued that first responders don’t usually take that much time. However, Campos mentioned in her social media post that there was a massive traffic disruption with four lanes blocked, causing a delay in the first responders’ arrival. She stated that people who were not there did not understand the nature of the situation the two were in.

Schaub and Campos were already taken back by the accident, and seeing another guy nailed by a car as he made his escape, the leaking gasoline, the kids screaming for help, and their dead mother behind the wheel was all surreal. Campos stated that the two did not have the time to think but that all their actions were instantaneous.

Murder Suspect Arrested as the Story Unfolds

The local police started their investigation into the accident to get to the bottom of what happened on the 101 freeway. As the California Highway Patrol gathered evidence, it revealed something horrifying. A 31-year-old man named Cesar Iban Torres drove the wrong way on the 101 freeway with his family in the car with the clear intent of killing them.

He tried to flee the accident scene but got hit by a car. The first responders attempted to take the man into custody for questioning. However, he tried to resist arrest but failed. When ABC7 News contacted Torres’s brother Juan Zavala after the accident, Zavala said that he received a phone call from Torres stating that he had to give his family to God.

The surviving kids reported that their mother, Aimee Garcia, a 26-year-old woman, saved the children. The oldest child, 8-year-old Ceasar, mentioned how his mother tried to take control of the wheel even until the last moment. Angie Fuentes, Aimee Garcia’s aunt, told the media that Cesar was the only witness who could recall what he saw inside the car.

On August 16, 2021, the court charged Cesar Iban Torres with several charges, including murder, four counts of child abuse, and four counts of attempted murder, assault, and resisting arrest. The District Attorney at the time, George Gascón, expressed his grief over the incident, stating that the wrong-way driving collision tore apart the family, leaving four kids moderately injured. The court also set Torres’s bail at $1 million and scheduled his arraignment.

GoFundMe Page to Cover Funeral Expenses

Angie Fuentes set up a GoFundMe campaign to raise money for the mother’s funeral and an apartment for the children to live in. She mentioned in her campaign that Garcia died, leaving behind four beautiful children and needed money to survive; otherwise, they would end up in foster care.

The target for the GoFundme campaign was $30,000, but within a few days, it crossed the $69,000 mark. Even former UFC fighter Brendan Schaub reached out to Angie Fuentes to discuss how he could help and contribute to the cause. Schaub mentioned that he wanted to create a college fund for the children and pay for their mother’s funeral.

History of Domestic Violence Surfaces

Many Americans couldn’t understand how a father could murder his partner and attempt to murder his four children. The story did not make sense until Angie Fuentes disclosed the details of their relationship leading to the car wreck.

Fuentes stated that the couple had met when Garcia was 16 and studying in high school. She mentioned how her niece was a victim of domestic abuse for several years, and when the family would approach her about this situation, Garcia would make light of it and try to avoid the questions. At one point, Garcia ended up in the hospital to get stitches, to which Fuentes expressed her concern about the situation she and the kids were in well before the car wreck.

Fuentes said that although Garcia did not have a mom or a dad, she gave all her kids unconditional love and took them everywhere she went. Fuentes was also infuriated by the ordeal and expressed her desire for Torres to suffer in prison for the rest of his life for causing the car wreck. Fuentes cried while speaking to the media that she was the one who cut Garcia’s umbilical cord, and now she is the one planning her funeral.

Citations:

  • The Fighter and the Kid Podcast

Domestic violence can affect the victim and those around them, leading to vehicular homicide, e-car wrecks, and more if you’re a victim of a domestic violence car wreck, let us stand by your side and provide you with the legal protection you need so you can avoid a wrongful death or serious injuries. Contact us at +(833) LETS-SUE and learn about your rights.