Skip to main content

Author: MichaelEhline

Wrongful Death and Punitive Damages Under California Law

Ultimate Guide to Understanding Wrongful Death Punitive Damages

Although Rare, You Can Be Awarded Exemplary Damages in a CA Death. What a tragedy! Nothing can cover the emotional trauma the loss of your loved one is causing you, and it is even more traumatic to think that you lost a loved one due to someone else’s negligence or recklessness.

A Wrongful Death Claim and Punitive Damages

One of the best ways to hold the negligent party liable is to file a wrongful death claim. With the help of a professional, aggressive wrongful death attorney, you will get a wide range of economic and noneconomic damages for your loss.

However, some families may want to recover punitive damages in a California wrongful death incident.

What Are Punitive Damages?

Seeking punitive damages, or “exemplary damages,” means using a process to discourage future wrongful conduct that was horrific. Because the acts were so disgraceful, punitive damages are designed to punish the negligent party for their neglect and give them a deterrence from any similar future misconduct beyond a typical wrongful death lawsuit.

Physical Recklessness and Lies Leading to Death?

The court could award punitive and compensatory damages if the judge finds the defendant’s actions were reckless, violent, negligent, or fraudulent. California has many statutes against deceit and intentional misrepresentation. Here are the basic definitions

  1. Malice,” for this article, means conduct that the defendant intends to cause harm to the plaintiff or conduct carried out with a willful and conscious disregard for the rights or safety of others.
  2. Oppression refers to inhumane treatment that subjects a person to cruel, severe, and unjust suffering.
  3. “Fraud” is a fraudulent intent to deprive another person of property or legal rights through the intentional false statement, concealment, or misrepresentation of a material fact known to the defendant. Fraud includes any conduct that subjects victims to deliberate deception, concealment, or misrepresentation of a material fact intending to deceive.

The nature of the conduct must be horrific or egregious. In 1941, the California Supreme Court decided a defendant who performs an act “intentionally with the knowledge that it will probably cause harm” may be held to answer for and pay damages above and beyond those typically awarded in traditional negligence cases. (See, e.g., Donnelly v. Southern Pacific Co.)

Although the compensation awarded in punitive damages is relatively minor compared to economic or noneconomic damages and sorrow caused, it can significantly help personal injury attorneys relieve survivors’ financial difficulties during arduous wrongful death actions as determined under California law.

Getting legal advice is essential to ensuring the survivors’ preservation of exemplary damages for the victim’s estate and punishing the defendant’s conduct. The above are all relevant factors, but what does California say?

Are Punitive Damages Allowed in California in a Wrongful Death Lawsuit?

No. California law does give a deceased person’s heirs the right to seek damages for economic losses and noneconomic damages associated with wrongful death lawsuits to a significant degree.

However, a wrongful death lawsuit will not allow a survivor to recover any punitive damages or for pain and suffering for this type of wrongful loss under California wrongful death law statutes. (See also, Ford Motor Co. v. Superior Court (1981) 120 Cal.App.3d 748, 751.)

Why is A Survival Action Important?

California wrongful death and survival claims differ here. The deceased’s estate, not you, will win you punitive damages through the deceased companion’s survival action portion of the case.

In a related personal injury lawsuit, this case is filed by appointed personal representatives acting on behalf of the decedent’s estate. (California Code of Civil Procedure §377.34)

These rules apply for a guardian ad litem seeking punitive damages on behalf of a surviving child for the decedent’s death when they are a parent. “California permits recovery in a child’s wrongful death action for loss of a parent’s consortium.” (See, e.g., Boeken, 217 Cal.App.4th at pp. 997-998.)

Our law group has successfully handled cases similar to Boeken, supra, with a high degree of care under California statutes.

We have helped with defective products related to killings and outright murder, entitling survivors to wrongful death benefits. We get victims justice, whereas others settle for less.

Only the Estate Can Get Punitive Damages.

Yes. Sometimes, a putative spouse has the right to ordinary damages. And even parties not generally entitled to intestate succession may be entitled to companionship damages.

On the other hand, only the dead person’s estate is entitled to seek an award of punitive damages.

In other words, such damages in a survival action are awarded in addition to damages for lost household services, property damage, or even lost future gifts. If you survived the decedent and are entitled to take, there is a probability you can prove these damages.

A domestic partner or close family member can only pursue legal rights through a survival action as the estate’s representative and only on behalf of the estate itself. Any related punitive damages claim where the decedent sustained an economic or noneconomic loss before death is fair game to sue a defendant.

Mere Negligence Alone Won’t Capture Punitive Damages?

Simply being negligent is not enough to get you punitive damages. But yes, California permits recovery under the California Civil Code for any person’s wrongful conduct resulting in severe injury or egregious accidental deaths as losses suffered for survival actions.

Even then, the punitive damages awarded must be reasonable. The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled the Due Process Clause to the Fourteenth Amendment mandates verdicts be reasonably related in proportion to the plaintiff of the survivor’s estate’s actual losses.

The economic loss giving rise to a survivorship claim is often lost wages, medical expenses, or any other monetary loss the decedent had before death. However, whatever financial loss the decedent incurs before their end is a necessary precondition to a survivor action and a punitive damage claim.

What Damages are Recoverable in a Wrongful Death Action?

A California wrongful death claim allows you to seek compensation and damages in wrongful death cases involving a felony, homicide, or other actions.

However, you can’t recover any punitive damage under a wrongful death claim for the wrongful act. It will need to be filed as a survival action claim. Elder abuse cases are prime examples where a court would award a plaintiff who wishes to seek exemplary damages to punish a nursing home for making a public spectacle of it all. There, the decedent’s estate would seek punitive damages, and the court would make sure they were not grossly excessive.

Suppose your victim died in a typical car accident. In that case, the plaintiffs could seek damages for things like moral support and loss of sexual relations for the loss of the family member over the decedent’s life expectancy.

If punitive are granted under related survival actions, there must be a reasonable relationship between the noneconomic damage and economic damages awarded to the decedent’s estate.

You can claim wrongful death damages, including financial compensation for medical bills, burial expenses, and the loss of the decedent’s financial contributions, funeral expenses, and noneconomic damages, including compensation for grief and cruel and unjust hardship. In a wrongful death case, we consider every instance of personal injury as a result of despicable conduct.

Surviving family members of the deceased person can file a wrongful death suit if the victim’s death is because of another person’s negligence or reckless behavior to prove death. But that doesn’t mean the survivor suffered the pain or torture. At least, they can’t claim unless the plaintiff was forced to perceive or view the evil acts of the decedent, killing the decedent in front of the survivor. In that case, you’d have additional causes of action for false imprisonment, negligent infliction of emotional distress, and others.

Although monetary awards cannot compensate for the loss of human life, the civil court tries to establish an amount that would pay the family for their tragic loss of money and enjoyment of affection under California civil jury instructions, no matter the dead person’s age.

Under the rules, expert personal injury lawyers consider several factors when establishing monetary compensation for a wrongful act. Any personal legal injury working to deprive a person of money and love is factored into deciding the expected monetary award.

This will be granted to the surviving heir or heirs for a death that occurred unless the plaintiff loses their case. However, the basic idea is to compensate the family for economic damages and noneconomic losses at present cash value.

To recap, in addition to the above damages, we have punitive damages when the conduct was so oppressive or destructive that it deserved punishment.

Generally, besides these two types of compensation, you can also benefit from punitive damages if the court considers the defendant’s behavior as willful and conscious disregard.

How Are Punitive Damages Calculated in California?

When a jury determines that a defendant has acted with oppression, fraud, or malice, they may decide that an award of punitive damages is appropriate. Also, if the decedent was murdered and made to suffer yet survives for a time before dying, this is a crime for which a degree of civil punitive damages may be paid when proven.

The plaintiffs must prove This bad conduct in court against those who caused or contributed to this assault on decency. (examples include cases of torture and disfigurement, including limousine passengers burned alive and other common carrier accident cases.) How is the amount of these damages calculated in such a claim?

Factors Relevant to the Calculation in Wrongful Death Claims

A jury will consider convincing clear and convincing evidence only when calculating punitive damages. It would help if you had the backing of a highly experienced personal injury attorney to establish your claim, whether from wrongful death or punitive damages.

For instance, the jury will look into the case to determine how reprehensible the defendant’s conduct was and the extent of the physical harm.

You cannot simply increase punitive damages because a defendant has significant financial resources. The law bases the calculation solely on the defendant’s willful actions. Punitive damages must be “relatively proportionate” to the actual damages award. In most jurisdictions, punitive damages cannot exceed four times the compensatory damages.

What is the cap on punitive damages in California?

California law does not cap the punitive damages a plaintiff can get in a lawsuit. To be successful, punitive damages must be “reasonable and proportionate to the amount of harm to the plaintiff and the general damages recovered.”

There are treble and double damages awards.

What are the Treble and Double Damages Awards?

A treble damages award is when a plaintiff gets punitive damages three times or triple the award amount. For example, if the compensatory damages amounted to $10,000, a treble damages award would allow the plaintiff to collect $30,000.

Similarly, a “double” damages award would result in two times the average damages. Only judges can award double and triple damages when they deem them appropriate.

To collect a double or treble damages award, the state must have a statute approving such awards, and the plaintiff needs to request the award specifically.

Do Insurance Companies Have To Pay Punitive Damages?

No. The insurance company is forbidden from paying punitive damages to the victim’s estate. It would encourage people to engage in arbitrary punishments of others since wrongdoers would know insurance would pay the reasonable value for everything causing injury to others, intentional or reckless.

Fighting to Recover Punitive Damages in California

Have you sustained severe personal injuries because of another person’s reckless or intentionally wrongful conduct? If their actions demonstrate oppression, fraud, or malice, you might have the right to recover an award of punitive damages for financial support.

The jury will add these punitive damages to any other compensation you receive. Contact the Ehline Law Firm Personal Injury Attorneys, APLC, for legal advice to pursue the compensation you and your loved ones deserve. We will thoroughly review your case during your free consultation and determine if punitive damages may be available.

If you have lost a loved one in California due to the negligence of another party, it is essential to understand your legal options for damages. You deserve the best professional legal team to advise you on choosing between filing a wrongful death lawsuit and a survival action.

Statute of Limitations Problems?

Wrongful death and survival actions are different and have differing filing rules. An exception may or may not apply in your case. Even if you qualify to sue now, you may not be able to do so later unless you sue within two years of death in most cases.

Sometimes, when suing a government defendant or subdivision of the state of California, for example, your circumstances must satisfy a general make your claim within six months rule, or surrender your rights to compensation against any varying type of defendant forever!

Assistance from personal injury attorneys at our law group can deter you from losing your rights after suffering the loss of a loved one. But you should contact someone who represents plaintiffs for a living. Don’t be guilty of thinking the insurance company wants to help you. This is a lie.

They don’t! They will speak compassionately and respond with untimely, absurd settlement offers or run out of time to sue for compensation in civil court. Common sense says to get a risk-free consultation from Ehline Law Firm.

Your health depends on responsible legal guidance after suffering such horrific wrongdoing, grieve, and recover from your new limitation of solitude or separation.

Schedule a Free Consultation With A Los Angeles Wrongful Death /Survival Action Lawyer

Are you suffering emotional distress over all the hassles with making a survival action claim? Here at Ehline Law Firm, we have been representing clients in wrongful death lawsuits and survivorship claims for a long time. Our ultimate aim is not only to help recover maximum compensation for the emotional, psychological, and financial loss suffered due to the loss of a dear one, but we also want to help you get back on your feet.

Parents, children, and other victims can contact us today to discuss their or the person’s damaged rights and any claim they wish to make regarding the malicious loss of their lifestyle and happiness.

A personal expert injury or wrongful death attorney is waiting to answer your call or email a website contact form for a free case review.

Wrongful Death Examples Wrongful Death Examples

What Is the Difference Between Murder and Wrongful Death?

Do You or Your Family Have a Case?

Do you file a wrongful death lawsuit or murder case if your family member dies due to someone else’s negligent acts? Let’s hear what a premier Los Angeles wrongful death attorney says.

Understanding the difference between murder (a criminal facing murder charges case) and wrongful death (civil lawsuit) might help you weigh your legal choices and decide if retaining personal injury attorneys is best for your surviving family members. Learn the details and standards of proof of legal representation with experience here.

The Difference Between Wrongful Death and Murder

Some individuals get perplexed by the distinction between wrongful death and murder cases. Material facts make the difference.

Civil and criminal lawsuits are the two most common cases in the United States. Individual residents file lawsuits against each other in civil proceedings (or against insurance companies or organizations representing people or businesses.).

Individuals who hire their private counsel can bring a civil case. Civil litigation, with the exception of contempt, rarely results in jail (at least not directly, which means unless somehow the evidence provided in a civil suit shows that criminal penalties by the state are warranted); however, it results in the payment of damages. State prosecutors filed a criminal charge on behalf of victims and the state.

Murder vs. Wrongful Death: Criminal Cases vs. Civil Cases

Murder

Criminal intent is what determines whether or not someone is guilty of murder. Murder gets committed when someone kills another person on purpose. Wrongful death cases can occur as a consequence of malicious intent, but they can also occur due to accidents or irresponsible conduct.

Wrongful Death

A civil action results in a wrongful death lawsuit. This means that the wrongful death case gets brought by the deceased’s family or the estate because the defendant was responsible for the victim’s death as a result of a purposeful or negligent act.

Murder lawsuits, on the other hand, are criminal cases, which means the state files the criminal murder charge because the defendant committed illegal conduct in society.

Murder is, in essence, a form of wrongful death, but the state is the client. Not all wrongful deaths, however, are murders.

Case In Point: Orenthal James Simpson (OJ Simpson) was initially charged with first-degree murder for assassinating his ex-wife and food service worker Ron Goldman. The surviving family of Nicole Brown Simpson or Ron Goldman didn’t file a criminal case. The only class member was from California.

But after the “not guilty” verdict was returned, Ron Goldman’s serving family sued and won a considerable money judgment against OJ, which OJ has desperately evaded paying.

The Burden of Proof

Since murders are always considered a criminal offense, the prosecutor must prove the defendant’s guilt “beyond a reasonable doubt.” Remember, however, the actual family members are not the client, so the material representation is not on their behalf.

Wrongful death lawsuits, alternatively, have a different burden of proof because of the party, parties, or anyone involved in litigating civil claims.

If the surviving family hires a wrongful death lawsuit attorney, the family becomes the client. If the family represents itself in a propria persona, it is a self-represented civil client in a wrongful death suit.

In wrongful death suits, the plaintiff’s lawyer must show that the defendant is more probable than not (by a balance of probabilities) to blame for the death case. This is called the civil “preponderance of the evidence” standard. (Compare this to the criminal burden of proof standard for a murder conviction.)

This means the plaintiff’s friendly and charismatic attorney must persuade the jury that the defendant committed the claims in the civil complaint with a probability of at least 51% in a wrongful death action.

DUI Driver Example

Take, for example, a DUI or narcotic intoxicated driver who slays another person. That drunk driver could be charged with a crime by the Los Angeles City Attorney or Los Angeles District Attorney.

Simultaneously, the surviving victim’s loved ones and close family members can hire a personal injury attorney to file a civil case under California wrongful death law against the criminal.

To recap, wrongful death is a legally specific type of civil action. Unlike a criminal action, the family and not the state is the actual victim, giving a survivor the right to pursue damages for the loss of the decedent human being in a wrongful death claim.

I say human beings because there is no murder case or wrongful death case for losing an animal. Murder is a criminal act against a human being only!

Finding Justice: Wrongful Death Cases vs. Murder

Homicide cases involve a corpus delicti (damaged party) and the alleged “true victim” (the People of the State of California). A murder or even a manslaughter conviction can result in a prison sentence or the death penalty in the criminal court, based on the jurisdiction and its statutes.

On the other hand (in contrast), in wrongful death lawsuits, the sole available remedy is the plaintiff’s financial compensation, not degrees of punishment. The only “punishment” available in a wrongful death action is an award of punitive damages. (These are typically awarded in cases involving malice aforethought, etc.)

If a criminal defendant is found guilty of civil wrongful death allegations, they must compensate the victim’s family or estate financially as per the civil court. (Death of a child could result in a wrongful birth lawsuit under your state’s abortion laws) The wrongful death or survival action defendant may not risk jail or other criminal punishments unless criminal charges are successfully brought.

Although no money can make up for a loved one’s loss of life, it is vital to cover final expenses or ensure your family’s financial security through a wrongful death lawsuit. This is particularly true if a person or a family relies on the deceased loved one for financial aid or support. This is why a free case review from an attorney with experience matters for damages outside the criminal court.

Do You Need Assistance with Filing a Wrongful Death Lawsuit? Schedule a Free Case Evaluation Today!

Contact Ehline Law Firm if you or a close loved one needs assistance navigating the complexity of pursuing a wrongful death suit for the actions of another, murder conviction or not.

Our wrongful death attorney in Los Angeles can assist you in obtaining just compensation for the tragic death of a loved one.

We recognize that no amount of money can make the agony of losing a loved one go away. However, we are also mindful that a wrongful death suit can assist wrongful death/murder victims with financial losses and other expenses.

Allow us to assist you at this trying time. You can rely on us to give the best legal advice in your economic justice quest. Learn more about forming an attorney-client relationship.

Call us at (213) 596-9642 or use the online contact form to schedule a free consultation to discuss your legal options regarding a wrongful death suit.

Magnum P.I. Actor and Legend Roger E. Mosley Dies After Car Accident at 83 Years Old

Star of Long-Running TV Series Passes Away Surrounded by Family

Ultimate Guide to Understanding Magnum P.I. Actor Death. Roger Earl Mosley has died at the age of 83. He died Sunday at quarter past one in the morning at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center with his loved ones beside him. Family members confirmed his passing on Facebook later that day. Mosley was known for his role as helicopter pilot Theodore TC Calvin on the much-loved TV show Magnum P.I., but he will first and fondly be remembered as a great man by all who knew him personally.

The Peaceful Passing Comes Days After Car Accident

Three days before his death, Mosley was involved in a car crash in Lynwood, Los Angeles.

Few details have been revealed regarding the nature of the accident, but injuries reportedly left the Magnum P.I. star in critical condition and paralyzed below his shoulders.

Mosley’s Daughter Ch-a shared news of the incident via Instagram, urging fans to send love as he fought for his life. She stated that best efforts were being made to care for him and that his family was with him during a tough time for them. The social media post concluded with a touching tribute to his strength, calling him a lion, a trailblazer, and a role model.

He Would Hate Any Crying, says the Daughter.

Ch-a Mosley appeared on Facebook to announce the death of her father.

In her words, she said that they could never mourn such a fantastic man and that he would not have wanted tears. Instead, she asked fans to celebrate his memory and the legacy he left.

Remembering Roger Earl Mosley: An Amazing Man, Father, Friend, Coach, and Actor

In honor of said legacy, we briefly look back at some of the ways Mosley will be remembered.

Early Film and TV Career

Mosley’s list of TV appearances goes on, with highlights including Love Boat, Starsky and Hutch, and The Rockford Files. He later starred alongside John Wayne in McQ, a police drama from the mid-’70s.

Before he portrayed Theodore Calvin, he played Sonny Liston in the 1977 film The Greatest.

He is also well-known for his regular work in Blaxploitation films such as The Mack.

His 1976 film Leadbelly, where he played the iconic folk singer Huddie Ledbetter, was praised by renowned critic Roger Ebert. In a sidebar, Roger called it one of the best biographies of a musician he had seen.

A Decade of TV History Alongside Tom Selleck

Undoubtedly, Magnum P. I was the highlight of Mosley’s acting career. According to the show’s star, Tom Selleck, Mosley wasn’t bothered about the role of helicopter pilot Theodore TC Calvin.

According to an interview given by Mosley, his agent convinced him to do it because it starred some guy- Tom Selleck- whose pilots always failed.

The idea was to shoot the Magnum pilot, get paid, and then go home. As we know, Selleck’s Thomas Magnum was a hit with his right-hand man TC, and the show went on to run for more than 160 episodes.

Tom Selleck’s character was also joined by John Hillerman and Larry Manetti, who, together with Mosley, would thrill fans for eight seasons over eight years.

His final return to the screen was a reprise of his most famous role in the new Magnum P.I., starring Jay Hernandez.

A Dedicated Coach

Another side to Mosley was his dedicated community work as a track coach in the unified school district. He worked with countless youngsters, encouraging them to reach their goals and excel.

He may have played Coach Ricketts on the silver screen, but to his community, Coach Mosley instilled a work ethic, strong morals, and knowledge in the people he worked with.

Loving Family Man

Above all, he was a man who loved his family. He was married for almost 60 years to his wife, Antoinette, who outlived him and their son, Daughter, and grandson.

Mosley died surrounded by those who loved him the most.

Have You Lost a Loved One in a Car Accident in Los Angeles? Contact Ehline Law Today

Losing a loved one under any circumstances is challenging. It can be even more difficult to understand when somebody dies in an accident.

Ehline Law is the leading authority in car accident and personal injury law in Los Angeles, with years of experience pursuing wrongful death claims on behalf of victims’ families.

Let Us Seek Justice for Your Loved Ones so You Can Focus on Remembering and Paying Respect to Their Legacy

The team at Ehline Law fights for the justice you and your loved one deserve. If you have a case, contact the team of dedicated and passionate lawyers today and begin the road to healing.

Collaborative Teams Can Improve Elder Abuse and Financial Exploitation in US

Collaborative Teams Can Improve Elder Abuse and Financial Exploitation in USWorking collaboratively against elder abuse and financial exploitation has existed for decades, but they’re only getting recognition or acceptability recently in the form of multidisciplinary teams (MDTs). MDTs are still a relatively new concept, and most of it comes from experience rather than research.

Ehline Law and our Los Angeles, California, elder abuse attorneys continuously strive to fight for the rights of elder and financial abuse victims by holding nursing homes responsible for physically, mentally, sexually, and financially abusing their residents and recovering the compensation needed to help the victim and their family members move on.

Elder Financial Exploitation Statutes

The United States Department of Justice, including local and state governments, has enacted several legislations aimed at helping victims of physical, psychological, sexual, and elder financial abuse, including the Elder Justice Act, Adult Protective Services Act, Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, Adult Maltreatment Custody Act, and many more.

Reporting Elder and Financial Exploitation to Adult Protective Services

Adult protective services are the United States government’s social services that serve vulnerable adults, including older people and adults with disabilities (reduced mental functioning) suffering from abuse, neglect, or exploitation.

The official government organization reports abuse and elder financial abuse allegations to relevant United States government agencies, including law enforcement, the Department of Health Services, and others.

It’s straightforward to navigate through the official websites and find the information needed on these secure websites to report elderly physical, mental, sexual, and financial abuse. They may receive health care, and in cases involving financially exploited individuals, the financial institutions may be able to recover the person’s money back.

However, after the elder and financial abuse victims are safely connected to the system, the Gov websites fail to inform them of the challenging process they must endure. Unfortunately, as easy as it is to report financial abuse and other types of abuse, the system has a lot of shortcomings that the victims become entrapped in.

Introducing Multidisciplinary Teams to Cater to Physical, Sexual, Psychological, and Elder Financial Abuse

Every community is unique and differs politically, geographically, and demographically. It may vary in languages, religion, and traditions, but all communities can develop MDT to address the elder abuse around them.

Developing an MDT is challenging, and creating a team is no easy task. Grouping some professionals and calling it a “team” is far from ideal, as strong leadership—someone who can take charge and implement an MDT—is needed.

Often, there are leadership figures in communities who strive to improve the conditions of their society and advocate for change regarding elder abuse. The leader must have strong leadership qualities, be charismatic, and have political influence or networking, allowing them to interact with multiple agency leaders and cooperate in achieving the community goals.

A significant trait of an MDT is flexibility. The team may work towards achieving their goals by doing it in a certain way, but with time, if they find that the particular strategy is not helping them reach their targets, they can quickly adopt another approach.

An MDT coordinator is responsible for ensuring that the team works together. However, there can be disagreements, and sometimes, a different structure may help the team perform better. Coordination and feedback from team members are critical to MDT’s success.

An MDT may also embark on activities other MDTs believe align with their goals. They may identify the community’s needs and address them accordingly. For example, an MDT in Texas decided to provide a senior nurse once a week to Adult Protective Services as a resource for their workers to achieve the goals of the Texan community. Such innovations are a great way to move forward and improve the outlook of the community the MDT represents.

Defining a Multidisciplinary Team

According to the Department of Justice, an MDT is a group of people from various disciplines working collaboratively toward a single goal and purpose.

The five main characteristics of MDT include the following:

  • Shared decision-making: The entire team is responsible for sharing information and participating in decision-making.
  • Partnership: MDT is a partnership with a Memorandum of Understanding or Interagency Agreement.
  • Interdependency: Every member of the MDT depends on each other, as MDT typically influences the outcome.
  • Balanced power: MDT does not have a single member that dominates the entire group, and everyone shares responsibility and authority. Equal input is one of the pillars on which an MDT stands.
  • Process: Team members work towards introducing protocols that resolve conflict and bring accountability into the case review process.

What Problems Do Multidisciplinary Teams Address?

Many MDTs specifically target older adults’ needs, especially regarding financial and elderly abuse. Some teams include elder fatality review, hoarding, mental illness, elder abuse, guardianship, financial abuse specialist, and code enforcement.

An MDT is not a new concept, but recently, there has been a growing acceptance of the need for one to tackle elder abuse in the United States. It is a victim-based approach designed to address the system’s shortcomings. An MDT aims to better understand elder abuse victims’ needs and priorities.

Why Is There a Need for Multidisciplinary Teams for Elder Abuse?

Elder abuse is not limited to physical, mental, and sexual abuse of the older person but also abandonment and financial abuse by another individual in a community, residential living, or care home setting.

Elder abuse has garnered massive public attention and greater societal awareness in recent decades. According to research, 10% of the elderly living in community, residential living, and care homes reported some elder abuse in the previous year. What’s concerning is most elder abuse cases do not receive the recognition needed.

Urgency in Identifying Abuse

There is an urgent need to identify and respond to elder abuse cases on the grounds of human rights and the consequences of it. For example, it is challenging for older adults to recover from the physical injuries and emotional trauma associated with the abuse, financial loss, and a higher risk of early mortality.

Most elder abuse victims make it into the system by reporting their issues to law enforcement or the relevant authorities assigned to cater to the older adult, such as Adult Protective Services (APS), Long-Term Care (LTC) Ombudsman Programs, and others. However, an official response responsibility lies with the APS, an agency that helps the elderly (60 years and older) and dependent adults (18-59 disabled).

The United States system aimed at resolving widespread elder abuse seems to fail on many fronts, especially when it comes to detecting and caring for the victims. This is why there has been increased attention to the subject lately. So, how does this system work?

Once the victim enters the system, multiple agencies follow up as part of the protocol. The APS or law enforcement authorities may visit the victim to understand the situation. Some victims might have to go through a neuropsychologist, who assesses their cognitive abilities, while others may have a physician treating and documenting the victim’s injuries.

The system will arrange for law enforcement officers to interview the victim and, in some cases, even provide them with a safe place to take them away from the abusive environment. Multiple agencies may work on the same case, complicating the process as each agency deploys its strategy and plans to cater to the needs of the abused elderly, unaware that other agencies are also planning on their side to achieve their goals.

The approach does not cater to the victim’s needs and is not victim-centered; it focuses on achieving these agencies’ organizational goals. It also does not respond to the needs of the perpetrators, which is considered a sustainable intervention strategy in understanding the root cause of the problem.

With multiple agencies working on the same case, it can become highly problematic, resulting in a system overload and many other problems, including:

  • Unfavorable outcomes for the victim
  • A constant back and forth from one department to the other for the victim
  • Interview duplication
  • Adversarial investigation
  • Lack of coordination between agencies
  • Contradicting recommendations
  • A poor understanding of the family’s needs and improperly addressing them with unnecessary interventions
  • Failing to address underlying problems
  • I was responding to one case without considering other potential victimizations.

The systematic failure signifies a need for one unit with experienced professionals from multiple backgrounds and agencies working collaboratively, taking charge of responsibilities, and participating in the decision-making process—a multidisciplinary team.

Benefits of an MDT Approach Toward Elder Abuse

Multiple agencies working together cohesively can complement each other. By working as part of the MDT, the various agencies bring their expertise to a case and collaboratively prevent the victim from becoming another by-product of the systematic failure to prevent elder abuse.

Each agency in the MDT has the opportunity to shine and share the burden of investigating and responding to complicated abuse cases.

For example, it is often difficult for the physical and elder financial abuse victim to trust a local police officer with sensitive information compared to an APS official. However, law enforcement is better equipped to gather the evidence the criminal justice system requires to expedite the case. On the other hand, APS can empathize with the victim and ensure they receive the necessary services.

Additionally, MDT team members can provide each other with the support needed, as sometimes, working on a complicated elder abuse case can lead to secondary trauma effects. Altogether, it is highly bebenefits and can lead to a better outcome.

Agencies partnering up with each other can benefit the victim in many ways, including:

  • Reduced duplicated interviews, various evaluations, and gathering evidence to support the victim’s case.
  • MDT makes it possible for the victim to receive coordinated services
  • Reduction in the number of systems the victim has to go through
  • Greater service awareness and improved access to services
  • Coordinated efforts mean tailored services incorporating their family member and their strengths
  • Multiple creative solutions arise from collaborative efforts
  • Enhanced monitoring and follow-ups to reduce the recurrence of abuse.

Schedule a Free Consultation with Ehline Law

Collaborative teams are now seen as a critical piece of the puzzle in solving the country’s rising elder physical, mental, sexual, and financial abuse cases. However, as of now, an experienced attorney is better equipped to help victims get away from the abuse, file a lawsuit against the nursing home, and fight for the compensation they deserve.

If you or your loved one is a victim of elder physical and financial abuse, contact us at (833) LETS-SUE for a free consultation with our California elder abuse attorneys, as you may qualify for compensation.

Can I Sue Over a Dog Scratch?

Can I Sue Over a Dog Scratch?Yes, you can sue under ordinary negligence. But no, dog bites are not treated the same as scratches under California Civil Code Section 3342 for liability purposes. True, dogs are our companions– they seem to be with us no matter where we go or what we do. But the dog owner is not without fault when things go wrong. Our canine companions are imperfect, especially if they are poorly trained or trained.

As a result, there are far too many dog bites and scratches across the United States each year. Most dog bite attorneys in California understand our dog bite statute and that strange dogs can harm or kill anyone. But when dog bite victims get scratched, is that included as part of the settlement or verdict?

What if the dog’s owner alleges it was just a scratch accident, and since there is no bite, the dog bite statute doesn’t apply?

Would this be handled similarly to the one-bite rule, mandating that the dog must have scratched someone else previously for the dog’s owner to be held liable? After all, not all dog attacks result in a bite.

For example, what if the dog wore a muzzle in compliance with the local leash and other dog bite laws? Were you trespassing, and the dog was trying to protect private property or other parties? Who can be sued, if anyone?

Before signing anything with the insurance company or dog owner, please read what our top-notch Los Angeles dog bite lawyers say. Learn here about vicious and not-so-vicious dogs that attack, including police dogs and service dogs in California, with or without teeth, causing an injury or death.

Non-Dog Bites, Dog Owners, and Legal Liability

But what if dangerous dogs still manage to jump on you, knock you down, or scratch you badly? These are exceptional circumstances for which you must immediately seek medical attention. What if the dog kills someone after toxic poisons from the dog’s paws penetrate their blood through open or torn skin?

What are the dog owner’s legal defenses under California personal injury law in such a dog attack? Does the dog’s breed play a role? What if the injured person provoked the animal on the dog owner’s property? Let’s find out more about dog owner liability and strict liability arising from something other than a dog bite claim.

More Information on Dog Scratches

Dogs typically have dirty paws from stepping on poop, feces, and other bacteria throughout their day. Below, we will look at options you or your loved ones will have regarding the aftermath of a dog scratch and associated diseases. Often, they’re more than just some superficial wound.

Too many people are hurt by such accidents annually, resulting in severe infections or even worse. In many states, a dog owner will be found liable in civil court and face criminal charges and jail time, especially in courts in states like Florida (See Fla. Stat. Section 767.136.).

For one, dog owners or maintenance personnel sometimes open a yard gate and allow the dog to roam the neighborhood. Let’s look at more information and some special precautions on how to avoid dog scratches and handle them properly.

Our expert attorney, Michael Ehline, writes about how to deal with this situation. In most instances, you didn’t try to get scratched. But Ehline Law is here to help press charges against the dog owner and deal with the insurance company or other organizations financially liable. Call us for a free consultation today by dialing (213) 596-9642.

Statistics on Annual Dog Scratches

First, let’s look at the information from the Centers for Disease Control. The CDC tracks the number of dog bites and scratches annually. They posted crucial information about these types of injuries here.

Furthermore, the CDC also posts related dog injuries, such as dog bites. More info can be seen here. There are multiple means by which a dog bite or animal scratch can cause damage in or outside the presence of a dog owner. One is due to the infection of the victim, bitten or not. Another is due to the risk of rabies.

Leading Cause of Rabies?

As the mammal most in contact with people, dogs are the leading cause of the spread of rabies. Rabies is a terminal disease and one that should be taken as seriously as possible by the negligence victim, even if scratched by a small puppy who escaped the side door, hole in a fence, or roamed in a public space like a dog park.

The CDC evidence shows that scratches are less likely to spread the disease than biting, but both should be taken seriously as the victim could still be killed in rare cases. This is especially the case when dealing with fluid, saliva, or blood exchange. Approximately 800,000 Americans are affected by dog bites annually.

Thousands are affected by dog scratches annually. A dog bite is often a significant concern as well. But the rules are still the same if you suffer a dog attack. The dog owner is strictly liable if the dog attacked an innocent person, bitten or not bitten. The more we know, the better. Fighting the effects of a dog bite or dog scratches is crucial.

Risks of Dog Scratches

Dog scratches often seem like a less severe issue than bites. In some ways, they are. That said, the substantial risk for adults and children injured by a dog remains. In some cases, this is due to an aggressive dog due to rabies. In other cases, dogs will attack someone they do not know, like a mail carrier. For others, it is due to a lack of training.

Regardless of the cause, a scratch can be a significant issue. This goes even more so for children. Dog scratches can range from a superficial wound to something that breaks the skin. When combined with dog bites, there are occasions where this is potentially fatal. For the average person, there is always a risk that a dog may become hostile. The more knowledge you have before an attack, the better you can avoid emotional trauma, bodily injuries, and property damage caused by other dogs.

Treating Dog Scratches

Treating dog scratches or some other injury sustained all comes back to severity. Some scratches are treatable at home. Often, the area should be washed extensively with soap and water. It should then be treated with an antiseptic. This is usually alcohol, hydrogen peroxide, or iodine. In certain circumstances, the dog owner is often familiar with this issue, whether due to scratches or a dog bite.

Handling More Severe Scratch Injuries

You or a loved one should visit the doctor for more severe scratches. Some scratches can wait for a regularly scheduled appointment. This is important to remember for scratch victims and dog owners alike. In other cases, the scratch should be treated as an emergency. The doctor will be able to handle the matter appropriately.

In some cases, the site will be cleaned. In others, there will be a need for stitches. Your doctor will also be able to administer a rabies shot if needed. Your doctor will know what to do. If you are not sure, you should seek medical treatment.

What Do I Do Next After a Dog Scratch?

This is a standard topic and one that should be taken seriously. For some, the answer is medical treatment. However, long-term issues are often related to a dog scratch, especially if it gets infected. If you or a loved one are at risk of being infected by rabies, special attention is necessary to avoid a much worse disease– and outcome.

One of the most common responses after medical treatment is to contact a skilled personal injury attorney. A specialized attorney will have the experience to handle and prove every element of what you or the scratched person will face. Their expertise in law school, with animals and the courtroom, will be crucial to the victim, bitten or not.

In some circumstances, compensation for such injuries is needed. Medical bills are often quite hefty, especially if uninsured or underinsured. They will rack up quickly and could burden your family significantly. This is especially the case when the injuries continue over a long period. Serious infections, such as staph infection, are a severe concern.

What Are Some Potential Dog Bite Injuries?

Earlier, we wrote about some potential injuries that could be caused by danger from dog scratches or while chasing you, jumping on you, and knocking you down. Dog owners and those who come in contact with their pets should know this. Dog scratches can be overlooked because of the seriousness of fangs and tooth bites. Rabies is a concern, as written about above. The pain and suffering go beyond this for the injured person, especially with dog attacks by dangerous breeds or scary breeds like Pitbulls and Rottweilers.

We have more info about that below.

  • Rabies: This is the most serious if your dog bites someone. It is less likely to occur in dog bites than dog scratches, but something to be guarded against as much as possible. Quick wound treatment is crucial to stop the risk of potential infection. The person with negligence may find their dog quarantined and destroyed for any damages caused by their unruly pet. (Think minor child victim badly lacerated by sharp paws.
  • Topical infection is perhaps the most pressing and common form of injury caused by dog scratches. Dogs are often exposed to the elements, and their scratches can cause severe infections. Some can lodge under the skin and cause anything from discomfort to surgery, especially with the issues below.
  • MRSA or Staph infections. These are less common but a concern, reported by scratched bicycle riders and U.S. mail carriers. Drug-resistant infections, such as MRSA or Staph, can land you or a loved one in the hospital. They must be taken seriously—treatment early on after the scratch should be able to avoid many of these effects. However, untreated wounds are still likely to cause these types of infections.
    Furthermore, they could also happen in fully treated wounds. Such infections can lead to hospitalization or even the risk of losing a limb. While they are less common than a topical infection, the risk of serious injury or hospitalization is enough that they must still be taken very seriously.

How Do I Contact a Dog Scratch Personal Injury Lawyer?

Whether dealing with a severe dog scratch or a dog bite, you should cover all your bases. Often, after medical treatment, this includes contracting a skilled personal injury lawyer.

Above, we wrote about the importance of such an attorney. Below, we will write about some key reasons why an attorney will be necessary for where you are headed. There is a good rule of thumb in cases like this– if you are unsure, you should contact an attorney. We will show below why and how this is a good idea.

Essential Points Before Suing a Dog Owner or Controller

  • Specialization. Calling an attorney who does not have a field in dog bites or scratches can be a big mistake. You may like and trust the attorney who filed your divorce papers or closed the deal on your house, but they may not be the right person for this job. Instead, an attorney who is well-versed and practiced in personal injury, especially dog bites, is critical. This applies whether you are the injured person or the dog owner. Dog owners could also benefit from having the right advice from an expert.
  • They are working on contingency. Many attorneys charge a retainer fee for their services. There are cases where this is the best path forward. However, many attorneys work on retainers, especially in cases of dog bites or scratches. They know the dog bite statutes and are willing to go to war to help you recover physically and medically. Such attorneys will be there and will not charge you a cent unless they win. This can be crucial for families dealing with the severe issues of a dog bite or scratch. The same goes for dog owners. Attorneys working on contingency are not paid unless they recover for the client. Having someone who won’t keep billing for work before the case is argued is critical.
  • Some families prefer retainers— and have the thousands of dollars necessary to make this happen. However, attorneys who work on contingency and those who work on retainer are equally skilled. Many attorneys will do both, depending on the circumstances.

Attorneys who work on contingency charge different rates, but one of the most common is one-third of the overall recovery. This means that the injured person will have the necessary amount to handle all of the effects of the injury—both when it comes to physical healing and for the bills that the damage from the dog bite or dog scratch needs. Choosing an attorney working on contingency who understands the dog bite statutes is crucial.

What if My Canine Scratches Another Canine?

In almost all states, no compensation is allowed in negligence cases for any emotional trauma or harm to the injured animal or the person losing their companion animals, even if they perceive the injuries as they occur.

The Importance of Working with a Caring Attorney

You are working with you. You may be tempted to use your old real estate attorney. This may be the case, especially if you are a dog owner. However, dog owners and the injured have different concerns. Having an attorney who can competently deal with the dog owner’s insurance company and is always available to you and your family remains critical.

Some attorneys will work with you through anything you need. In some cases, they will cover the cost of medical expenses upfront. In others, they can pre-pay for future medical expenses. This can be the critical element needed to help your family recover in the way it needs to. Don’t discount it during a time of need for non-dog bite attacks.

Either way, the private property owner or dog owner has a legal responsibility to compensate the person injured, especially if the dog owner knew one of their pets bites people, or their large dog’s actions caused terrible scratches.

Whether it’s a small dog or a large dog, we can assist you in pursuing liability insurance money. Once you form an attorney-client relationship with us, we can help you recover financially for any injuries caused. If the settlement offer is too low, we can help you file a civil lawsuit against those legally responsible for causing your puncture wounds, lost wages, emotional distress, and other injuries a dog caused.

Who is the Best Los Angeles Dog Bite and Dog Scratch Attorney?

Fortunately, this one is easy—the Ehline Law Firm APLC. The firm has multiple offices up and down the Pacific Coast. And, even better, it has the best experience regarding dog bite cases coupled with severe injuries. This is the case for injured and unreasonably careless dog owners. Having the ability to handle dog bite and dog scratch cases is going to be the best possible feather in your cap.

Michael Ehline, a disabled Marine Corps veteran, virtuously and competently leads the Ehline Law Firm’s lawyers. He is a man who built the best team in Southern California. His military experience also showed him the importance of never giving up on your friends and comrades. He will not ask for a penny or give up one inch until he has won money damages for you in the face of the dog owner’s carelessness.

Speak with a Talented Dog Scratch and Bleeding Attorney in Los Angeles Today!

Not sure what to decide on after dealing with all this trauma from an infection after a dog attack? Look no further than his millions recovered for clients in various personal injury cases. He is there in cases of a dog bite or a dog scratch. He is there for you. He is the best option when recovering from a scratch or a dog bite.

Don’t blow the typical two-year statute of limitations and become time-barred from suing the negligent party. Contact Mr. Ehline or one of his star attorneys for more information. If we can’t win a significant settlement, we’ll bring your suffering before the judge and jury. If you have any questions, he can be reached at info@ehlinelaw.com.