Skip to main content
No, You Can't Always Protest With No Permit 101 for Dummies

No, You Can’t Always Protest With No Permit 101 for Dummies

Many First Amendment auditors think they know the law, but they mostly don’t. Here, I will try and help the ones intelligent enough to listen. As we navigate social, political, and environmental obligations, protest is vital for voicing concerns and demanding changes. However, balancing citizens’ rights to free speech and assembly with public safety and law and order is crucial. This finely drawn balancing act often necessitates permits when staging large protests and for good reasons. 

You may wonder why police officers at large protests will require a permit. Well, the reasons are multifaceted. Firstly, permits help local authorities manage traffic, prevent unexpected disruptions, and ensure the safety of all involved – protesters and non-protesters alike. Government agencies want to keep antagonistic groups separated as well. Also, in a dispute scenario where a permit has not been issued, having a full understanding of your rights can be pivotal. In such cases, challenging the decision through a lawsuit is viable, and hiring a proficient lawyer can redefine the outcome. 

“The right to protest is a fundamental human right endorsed by the Constitution’s First Amendment, but governments have the right to regulate protests. Permits are often required as part of such regulations. However, if you believe your rights are being infringed upon by the denial of a permit to protest, a suit filed by a competent lawyer can challenge this denial.”

This quote is snipped from our source at the American Civil Liberties Union’s guide on protester’s rights. The ACLU is widely respected for its extensive work defending and preserving individual rights and liberties. 

So, how can a lawyer come to your rescue? Here’s a list of things a lawyer can do: 

  • Help you understand your rights and advise you on your legal standing.
  • Assist with filing a lawsuit if your request for a permit has been unjustly denied.
  • Represent you in court and challenge the denial of your protest permit.
  • Provide guidance on how to keep your protest legal and peaceful in order to ensure your message carries weight without causing unnecessary legal trouble.

Engaging in protests is a powerful way to stand up for your beliefs. Keeping the legalities in check will only serve to strengthen your cause and ensure your voice is heard in the most impactful and respectful way.

Key Considerations for Protest Descriptions Permits

Government authorities can impose restrictions on protests by requiring permits. They are typically needed for large public gatherings to coordinate safety measures and manage potential disruptions.

Government Officials and Protest Rights

You have a constitutionally protected right to protest peacefully, particularly in traditional public forums such as streets, parks, and sidewalks. But when a police officer stops you, especially on private property, local and federal governments will usually err in favor of public safety or peacekeeping. And no, private property owners don’t have to order you away; police can remove protestors when things get crazy.

Preventing Interference

If your protest has a permit issued by government officials, the police may need to ensure private actors are prevented from interfering with your speech, preserving effective communication.

Clear and Present Danger Dispersal Order?

A dispersal order is a detailed notice issued by public officials, often against antagonistic groups blocking public streets. The idea is for police officers to treat protesters fairly since the First Amendment is designed to prevent interference with free expression. Hence, this will be usually be issued when the protestors are deemed hazardous. The police can issue a dispersal order if the gathering presents a clear and present danger of a riot, interference with traffic or a threat to the physical safety of those in the area. Yet, at the same time, shutting down a protest through a dispersal order should be law enforcement’s last resort. But if there is already a public street closure from protest activities, it starts to infringe on the rights of other persons. Also, allowing it to spiral can wrap normal people up in the criminal activity of rioters, including carjacking, etc.

Legal Consequences

Civil disobedience, such as blocking an intersection or chaining oneself to a building, may lead to arrests. An arrest can have different implications depending on your circumstances. It can lead to an excessive force civil rights case, or even a wrongful death. If you’re a non-citizen, it could even impact your immigration status.

Legal Recourse Against Government/Police Officers

The Supreme Court does not consider riots and unruly actions to be free speech. Sometimes, we have to let the courts decide after the fact. You can file a lawsuit if your rights as a protester are violated – like not being issued a permit without cause. The federal government will have laws different from the state, so look up the local laws before setting up a protest. Having a lawyer for this process would be beneficial for navigating through the appropriate procedures and submitting a compelling legal request.